Pointed Discussion

Magic: The Gathering Card Comments Archive

Grim Harvest

Multiverse ID: 122114

Grim Harvest

Comments (16)

Greatlordofall
★★☆☆☆ (2.4/5.0) (5 votes)
For a Coldsnap common, it's not bad.
asca
★★★★☆ (4.5/5.0) (7 votes)
Awesome utility card, recurs your dead dudes and works great with evoke and comes-into-play abilities. Not to mention it gives you more resilience against counterspells. Great!
Tommy9898
★★★☆☆ (3.7/5.0) (3 votes)
I hate playing against this card when I don't main board graveyard hate, so annoying with martyr of sands and even worse in Elder Dragon Highlander. So I guess it is a good card since it vexes me so much.
Studoku
★★★★☆ (4.5/5.0) (3 votes)
Graveyard retrieval that can be retrieved from the graveyard when something hits the graveyard (and you might want to retrieve it).

So much synergy- I love it.
Cyberium
★★★★★ (5.0/5.0) (3 votes)
This card goes well with all Echo creatures, since Echo creatures tend to be cheaper cost, have comes into play effect, and most importantly dies on its own, using the recover cost would be readily available.
Magnor_Criol
★★★★★ (5.0/5.0) (3 votes)
Played an EDH game tonight against a guy who had this and Fleshbag Marauder at the same time. It was brutal.

Cast Harvest, get a dude back. Cast Marauder, sac him to his own trigger and make everyone else sac a dude, Recover Harvest. Next turn Harvest for the Marauder, cast Marauder again, Recover the Harvest...rinse and repeat ad nauseam. Nasty.
RJDroid
☆☆☆☆☆ (0.0/5.0)
I never tested this out in EDH because I thought it was a sorcery, and because I was bad at the concept of repeated recursion. Now that I see that this is an INSTANT, and that in EDH you are likely to have spare mana floating around, I'm going to test this out.
ugotpauld
★★★☆☆ (3.5/5.0) (1 vote)
combos well with creatures
blobman
☆☆☆☆☆ (0.5/5.0) (1 vote)
The thing is you can use Reclaim or Reintomb for a less cost.
Lash_of_Dragonbreath
★★☆☆☆ (2.8/5.0) (2 votes)
@Blobman: no, the thing actually is that this card is reusable. So, while Disentomb may be 1 cheaper, this offers you card advantage. Also, in a dredge deck you could fish this out of your graveyard if you end dredging it by accident. And it's an Instant, so you can spend your spare mana on it at the end of an opponent's turn.
Not saying it's the best card ever, but it's still a nifty little trick to pull in casual or multiplayer.

On a side note, am I the only one who notices how well Void Maw works with recover?
Eluem
☆☆☆☆☆ (0.5/5.0) (1 vote)
Can't believe no one said it. Isochron Scepter
luca_barelli
☆☆☆☆☆ (0.0/5.0)
recurable recursion. I like it.
fibonacci112358
★★★★★ (5.0/5.0) (1 vote)
This is easily my favourite Pauper card.

This card absolutely destroys permission. A little bit mana-costly, but in the long-term it is very difficult to attrition against this card.
blurrymadness
★★★★★ (5.0/5.0) (1 vote)
I find recover *really* hard to use in general, it's really mana-intensive and designed for the long game. Great in G/B since you will likely get enough mana to make good use of it.
jonrds
☆☆☆☆☆ (0.0/5.0)
@lash_of_dragonbreath

I dont think void maw works with recover. Recover specifies "from play" but with void maw its from exile.
casualhorror
☆☆☆☆☆ (0.0/5.0)
Good use of Nature's Freezer, my good Chimney Imp! Yes, that is what this card should be used with the art even blatantly acknowledges the broken combo. Just run 52 Swamps, 4 of this and 4 Chimney Imps. Trust me just sleave it up and ̠̝̝̻̠̽ͥ͗ͫ͂͐H̭̞͍̳̣͚ͨͧ̓̌ͭ́a̖͍͙͈̒̍ͧi̯̭̗̰͙͗͊̍̅ͩ̆ͨl̘̳͓̦̥͔̽͜ ̶͊̌̇͒ͩ̚C̅̓̊͒͟hi̦̠̖̲̿͠ͅm̥̙̬̥̈́̎ͥͬͦ̚͠n̸̠͕̰̑̓̽̅̅ë̗̭̯̤̜̽̓y̥̟͓͇̪̯͗̽ ̶̹̫I̫̙̼̰̘͙̐̊ͬ͒͡m͉̰͈͇͉̩̓ṕ̛̮̤͎͌̏ͬ̃̃!̭͈͍͖̲̌ͭ̓ ̡͍̲̗͎ͨ͊͂̓́ͪ ̖̬͎̺̗͚̟ͫ̍ͥH͏̺a̹̹̼̅́̈͗̈͜ḯ̙̝̬̉̆̎̽l͚͖͙̠̩̤͓̉̐ͭ ̟͖̻̙̲̌̃̿͑͂ͩ̿C̀͛̾̑̒͏̟h̼̟̺̭̮͌ͨ̎i͂̆̉̅͛ͩ̚m͔͕̲͈̫̹͑̉̃n̝̗̄ͣ̉͒ͤ̅ͧ͝ḛ̸̪̙̫̝̭̽̈y͌ͯ͌̈́̓̑ͨ͜ ̵̜̱͍̗̘̦̘̔̈́̈̇̿̆̓I̝̲͇m̹͙̭̙͚͗͠p̤͔̣͋̂̔!͈̞̕ ̝̙̜̣̪̳̪͆͑ ̣̮͟H̹̭̯̹͔a͕ͭ̑̆̾̈̀̚i͈͔̙̙ͫ̇̈ͩ͆͞ͅḽ̜̅͊̑ͨ̉ͬͩ͢ ̲̩̆̂̅͊̾̒̚C̥h̺̹̑̊̊͝ĩ̙̙̩̆m̥̑̍͊͊͌̚n̗̲̝̹̝͎͎͌ĕ̘̥̄̃̀y͙̰͇̗͡ ̯̙̪͎̥͈̤̇̽̑Ḯ̮̬͈̕m̤̭̱̝̤͚̓ͩ͆̈́̚͘p̯̖͔͍ͯ̉̉!̯
̸ͣͪ͗ͧ͊̑͛ ͥ̇̂̂H̹̱̉ͮ̏a̶̗͂̅ỉ͙̗̪͙̼̈̐̉ͧ̏l͉̝̟͟ ̬̣͚͍̅ͅC͑ͩ͆͏͍̬̲͔̜̣ͅh͈̱̘̮̱̤̓ͬ͂̈͘ͅi̝̰m̢̭͛͋ͦ͐ṇ̼̻͝è̔y̞̤̜̬̝̆ͫ̒ͩ̓̄͗͟ ̢͓͈͍̪̯̠ͥ̊̅̏Ị̢͖̪̩̝͕͂́̂͂ͦm̭̮̜͇̓̍̌͐͘p̽́ͪ̊̌́͌!̵̯͉ ͬ͏͈̺ ̩̺̗͙̮̱͊̋ͪ̄ͧḦ̺̺̬͉̫̦́̎ͬaͪ̆ͣͬ͠i̲̹̓̉̔̾̚͜ͅl͏̦̣ ̡ͨC͎̰̗̓͌͋h̜̙͐̅̾i̼̹͓͙̦͇̚m͓̾ͯ̇͘n̺̓̄͋̇̔ë̬͗̊ͪ̚y̶̻̫͉̌̄̅̀ͫ͒ͅ ̳͙̹͚̺̫̂̾Ï͌̃҉̝̭̖̮ͅm͖͚̮̔̆̚p͎̦̘̭͎̩̫͒ͪ!̱̄̀ͭ̽̆̏̔ ͓͓̣̇͒̽͒̇ ͔͍̩͔̣̋ͣ̉ͮͫ͠H̩͍̼̖͊͐͞a̜̪̍i̊̀l̷͈͍̘̪̟ͅ ̳̼̤̩ͤ̑͒̋ͮ́C̬͍̣͔͚̘̘ͮ͛h͈̳͈̞͋ͣ͆i̩m̻̠̗̼ͣ́n̮̫͍̻͂͡e̡̬̥ͩy̮͎̝̠̺̥͎ͧ͌̊ͫ̽̏ ̣̪͙͈͇̦̉̓͊͜I͓̥̺̤͔ͤ̌͑͂ͩ͐ͯm̰̃ͨ̉p̸̻̥̿!̵̳͚̹̳̪̻̏̐̐͊͋̓͒ ͖ͯ͐ͧ̍ͣ̓ ̄̌̏͊͝Ḥ͇̟͍̔ͫ͌͋̉͛͟ȃ̗͗͂ͫ̍i̜͕͖̤̩͙ͨͥ̔̀lͮ̑̊͑ ̞̈̀̚͢C̤̺̥̠̰̽͌ͭh̨͕̖̠̤̓ͬ̏i͈̰ͦͦm͔̬͍͍͈̥̗n̬̥͖̘̟͠ḛ͔̱̙̻͓̓ͨ̆ͨ̏̏̄ŷ̝͚̱͉̆́͜ ̧̮̖̖̺̲̣̂̇̊͊̂̍ͣI̲̹͛ͮ͟m̜̾̄͆͊̕p̘̲ͦ̒̊̀!҉̣̮