Pointed Discussion

would have been so much better if you got to start.

Then it would have to be rare, but yeah that would make this card so much better. Still useful tho. T1 Swamp 2 dark rituals and you can mess someone up good if you went first. You can take their lands while they choose their baddies.OR Visa Versa

Here we see kamigawa trying to desperately not suck by making a card with "flavor". Sadly that flavor is cardboard.

What a mindf***.

A truly devastating card when mixed with Oppression and Bloodchief Ascension..

would have been BALANCED if you got to start! yeah, that version might have had to be rare, but at least it would be playable

I like this card soo much. It will almost always do SOMETHING. Worst something- they lose their 2nd best card which isn't great for 4 mana BUT, play it 10 times and watch 70% of the time as it affects the game. Best case scenario that I've experienced, playing with it in my liliana discard burn deck against draw with Venser's Journal and got to select 5 cards to toss into their boneyard, while hitting them for 10 Pts of damage. That was only once but it was T-Totally awesome nonetheless!

Interesting, but not terribly strong. I'd use it in a slower discard control deck for the fun/griefing factor.

Or you could just play Monomania for one more...

Basically chose 1-3 to discard for 4, and can see their hand. Fair card, can be devastating.