Pointed Discussion

I love art that depicts a gigantic sea creature lurking in the depths.

So do I, but this card is awful.
Can you say Magikthegatheringkarp?

When is four power for two mana bad? When it's Dandan. It falls into the trap that many cards in the early days fell into: if you're going to jump through hoops, you want a decent payoff. A four power attacker is fine, but not when it will almost certainly die the first time it attacks. The payoff here, of a one-toughness creature, just isn't enough for a card with islandhome. As, say, a 3/3 it would probably have been playable.

I didn't see the fish until just now. I used to think that the creature was the boats.