Pointed Discussion

Strictly better than Hill Giant.

Oh? I didn't know that Roc of kher ridge can be casted cheaper with Stinkdrinker Daredevil or can get boosted by sunrise sovereign and can let an ancient amphitheater come into play untaped, just like hill giant can.

Stop saying strictly better! 95% of the time you will be wrong and it makes you look like a dumb ass.

Why is it on the no-reprint list?

All the rares from the early sets were put on it if they hadn't been reprinted.

Tommy, it means the card itself is better in every way. It doesn't mean it interacts better with other cards. And it's a different creature type, so it's not strictly better, but barely.

Strictly better than... your face!

We did not mean to get your panty's in a bundle Tommy. Giant is not the most supported tribe, and even if you are playing giants your not going to be using hill giant. So its better in almost every way then hill giant so excuse us.

Magic needs more Rocs. Something along the lines of absurdly big flying creatures... They'd go well in , maybe even .

One of the top reasons why the Reserved List is stupid. Because of this card (which isn't even worth a meaningful amount of money to collectors anyway), Red can never have a 3/3 flying for 4 ever again.

Stupid, stupid, stupid. When are they going to discard the reserved list already? The people who wanted it moved on almost a decade ago; now it does nothing but hurt the game.